Effective date of EOU conversion controls excise duty liability; pre-conversion stock cleared as DTA cannot attract differential duty.

A DTA unit converted into a 100% EOU only from the effective date fixed by the Development Commissioner, and the pre-conversion stock was verified and allowed to be cleared as DTA goods. On that basis, duty could not be demanded for the period before the conversion date, because the competent authority had already determined when EOU status took effect. The notice seeking differential excise duty on the footing that EOU status applied from an earlier date was therefore unsustainable, and there was no basis for penalty.

---

---

Issues: Whether the appellant unit was to be treated as a 100% Export Oriented Unit from 19-11-99 and, if so, whether differential central excise duty and penalty were recoverable for the period prior to 16-5-2000.

Analysis: The unit had applied for conversion from DTA to 100% EOU and had obtained the Development Commissioner's permission. The customs licence under Section 58 of the Customs Act, 1962 was later granted, but the decisive factor was the Development Commissioner's communication confirming conversion of the unit into EOU with effect from 16-5-2000, with the stock in existence prior to that date to be treated as DTA products. The finished stock on 16-5-2000 was verified by the central excise authorities, and permission was given to clear that stock in DTA on payment of duty. In these circumstances, the show cause notice demanding duty on the footing that the unit had to be treated as an EOU from 19-11-99 was not justified. No differential duty liability arose for the disputed period, and there was no basis for penalty.

Conclusion: The demand of differential duty and the penalty were not sustainable and the issue was decided in favour of the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded and the impugned order confirming duty, interest, and penalty was set aside.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the competent development authority specifically fixes the effective date of conversion of a DTA unit into a 100% EOU and the pre-conversion stock is verified and permitted to be cleared as DTA goods, no differential excise duty can be demanded for the period before that effective date.

---